Everything Is Nice

Beating the nice nice nice thing to death (with fluffy pillows)

Archive for September 11th, 2009

Top Marks For Not Trying

with one comment

For some reason Alexis Petridis really doesn’t like Brianstorm. From his four star review of Favourite Worst Nightmare by Arctic Monkeys:

Brianstorm sounds like an entry in what seems to be a competition among major artists to see just how devoid of a tune a single can be and still make the upper reaches of the chart, raising the stakes substantially over last year’s winner, SexyBack by Justin Timberlake… Brianstorm’s lyrics are cut from the same sarky cloth as their debut single, Fake Tales of San Francisco, but listening to it you’re haunted by the thought that hearing a multimillion-selling rock star sneering at an unwanted interloper in his dressing room might not be quite as edifying as hearing a whip-smart teenager chuckling at his peers in the indie disco.

Two and a half years later, Petridis is stil stewing on this in his four star review of Humbug:

What you do when you’re removed from the environment that inspired you is a question their last album, Favourite Worst Nightmare, struggled to answer. It unsuccessfully tried adapting its predecessor’s arch, sarcastic stance to fit the world that Arctic Monkeys now inhabit on the charmless opener, Brianstorm

It is not one of my favourite songs either, it is too blunt to be one of their best, but Petridis seems off in his criticism. As he suggests, they have simply transferred their contempt from the local to the global music industry so I’m not sure why taking pot shots at an international promoter is less edifying than doing the same to kids with dreams of making it (whatever that means). And if he thinks the venomous Fake Tales is just indulgent chuckling he must be tone deaf. He is right about Cornerstone though.

Written by Martin

11 September 2009 at 07:46

Posted in music

Tagged with ,